I love it that while looking into one mystery, I find info on another.
One of the most frustrating mysteries that has been vexing me of late is the origins of Marcus Princeton Carter.
I just know he is connected to other Stanly County Carters, but how?
While looking for info on another 'parentless' Stanly County Carter, I came across the name of Marcus in an unexpected but reasonable place, in the estate records of Joshua Carter.
Now, I know estate records normally lend no proof of relationship or suggest any. However, after perusing dozens of estate records of families I was very familiar with, I've discovered that a large numbers of persons mentioned in estate records are usually family members, and if not, usually neighbors. But especially those persons of the same surname. While it does not 'name that relationship', it hints that you might be looking in the correct pumpkin patch.
An example of this would be in the estate record of Job Davis, for whom this blog is named. I've so researched this family that I knew who each person mentioned in the papers was. Every Davis mentioned was the son or grandson of Job. And persons like Jeremiah Broadaway, who no one would devise as a relative, I knew was his hmmm, 'step-grandson-in-law'. Two of Job's wife Sarah's sons by her first marriage, John W. and Jordan Howell, had migrated to Fayetteville, NC and settled there. After the death of Jordan, his daughters returned to Stanly County to live with their grandmother and step-grandfather, and met husbands who lived in this part of the state. Jeremiah Broadaway was one of those husbands and married Clarissa Ann Howell.
So, while I have discovered the name of Marcus Carter in the estate records of Joshua Carter, this by no means proves, mentions or suggests any relationship between Joshua Carter and Marcus P. Carter, but it could mean I need to search this pumpkin patch for more hints. I do believe that in the case of Marcus P. Carter, we have a case of what I call an "UnIdentified Dash". Many times, descendants will start a family with only the children who show up in the 1850 census, while the 1840 and 1830 census show other, older "dashes" who could be children, possibly those who are grown up and on their own by 1850. If the parents die intestate and no land records indicate descendants, then there is nothing to tie these older, independent children to their parents.
I do believe this is what happened with our Marcus. I've poured over family trees and information on other Carters, and feel Marcus is just an unidentified dash in the 1840 and 1830 census of an established Carter family of early Stanly County. He did not fall from the sky.
And now for the estate record of Joshua Carter:
An Inventory of the personal property of Joshua Carter, deceased, which came into my hands as his Administrator- -Account on David Crowell .50 " on Peter Crowell .50 " on Francis Locke .52 total 1.52 all desperate--- 2 Head Cattle, 16 Head Hogs, 1 Rifle gun, 1 bed and furniture, 1 Wheel and Cards, 1 Loom, 2 Barrels, 1 bush. Salt, 1 Clock Reel, 1 paddock, 1 lot sundries, two mattocks, 5 axes, 1 shovel, 1 tub, 1 cutting knife, 1 lot ploughs, 1 single tee, 2 pots, 1 skillet, 1 oven, 1 cupboard, 1 lot Ware, 1 lot knives and forks, 1 pail, 1 piggin, 1 toilet, 1 chest, 1 weeding hoe, 1 pr. Hames and Traces, 1 pr Steelyards, 1 drawing knife, 1 adze, 2 planes, 1 croze cutter, 1 hand saw, 1 lot books, 5 chairs, 1 hammer and chizel, 1 lot Oats, 1 potatoe patch. Note on MARCUS CARTER and James Parker 17.43 " Nathan Carter and Samuel Morton 3.85 " John Morris and William Morris 1.65 " Calvin Carter & James Parker 1.28 " Alex. Kirk & Samuel P. Morton 1.30 " Josiah L. Carter and Nathan Carter 11.53 " Nancy Carter and Nathan Carter 7.66 " Benjamin New and Edmd. W. Lilly 1.27 " James Parker, Sr. 1.87 " Francis Locke .55 " Samuel S. Stone .81 " Daniel Biles 1.00 " Samuel P. Morton .60 " George C. Morton .20 " John A. Craven 23.62 Travis Carter, Administrator Returned to August Sessions 1842 & ordered to be recorded.
Marcus Carter would have been a young man, just coming into himself and of age in 1842.
His note, in conjunction with James Parker, is the largest, with the exception of that of John A. Craven. Perhaps if I look into the relationships between Joshua Carter and the other Carter's mentioned in this document, I will discover a possible connection to Marcus.
James Parker is also mentioned on a note in conjunction with Calvin Carter. Then later, a James Parker Sr., to himself. I also want to know the connection to James Parker.
I have the advantage of knowing what individuals were businessmen in the community who had a financial interest in many local farmers and individuals. For instance, Samuel S. Stone, Daniel Biles, Edmund Lilly and Francis Locke. No relationship there, or not likely to be.
I also know my ancestor, Samuel P. Morton, was a minister.
So, finding Marcus Carter's name in a document involving other Carters is a big find. Proof of nothing, but hopefully a lead to something.
Martha Jane Rummage was born about 1845 in Stanly County, North Carolina, probably close to the Porter community. She died July 3, 1936, and was the daughter of David Rummage and Beadie Frances "Fanny" Cranford Rummage. She was the granddaughter of George Rummage II and wife Margaret "Peggy" Simpson, a sister of Nathaniel Simpson. Several of my more recent posts have focused on this family. She was also the granddaugther of Nathan Christopher "Kid" Cranford and Sarah Elizabeth "Sacky" Coggins Cranford.
The first census she shows up in is the 1850 one with her siblings Henry, Adaline, Lindsey, William, Elizabeth and Irvin.
Her mother, Beda (possibly short for Obedience) passed away April 25, 1858, when her youngest daughter was only 13 years old. This must have had an indelible effect on Martha Jane.
Older sister Adaline, stayed with the family well into her twenties. She must have been helping her father take care of her younger siblings and the housework. Adelina married that same year to Z. D. Blalock and by 1870, for Martha, the tides had turned.
This family grouping is not exactly as it appears. Looking at the original document, "Louisa" is more like "Lonna" and the child was a male. David Rummage is still alive and living with his two daughters, Elizabeth, who was known as Bettie, and Martha Jane. "Lonna" Rummage is actully Bettie's son, Lonnie Oscar Rummage. In 1879, Bettie married Balaam A. Carter. In the 1880 census, Lonnie is incorrectly shown as Lonna O. Carter. The transcriptionist also incorrectly labeled "B. A." as "S. A." and "Bettie" as "Tellie". Looking at the original document, with the family being in the same location between neighbors as Balaam Carter was 10 years prior, you can see the B A and the Bettie. Polly was Balaam's mother.
Lonnie Oscar Rummage was married twice and on both marriage certificates, only his mother, Bettie Rummage is listed. It is unknown who his father was. Joseph Rummage never shows back up, so most likely passed away as a child, and was probably also the son of Bettie.
Following the path of her older sister Bettie, it was not long before Martha Jane also became "a bird in the branches". David Rummage died October 26, 1876, leaving his unmarried daughter alone. The 1880 census painted a much different picture.
In 1880, Martha is now the mother of 3 children. She was most likely expecting Mary already in the 1870 census, and took care of her father until the birth of son Richard.
While researching the Simpsons, I discovered this document:
The child would be Lee Allen Rummage, Martha's fourth child and J. B. Simpson was John Brantley Simpson, son of Thomas and Judith (maiden name unknown) Simpson Cagle.
On October 10, 1889, Martha Jane Rummage gave birth to her fifth child and fourth son, Millard Talbert, at the age of about 42 or 43. Two years later, she would marry his father, widower William H. H. Talbert (or Tolbert). I will use Talbert, as this is how the living descendants spell their name locally.
William H. H. Talbert was the son of Isham Talbert and Edith Crowell Talbert. His first wife was Nancy Emmaline Rummage, the daughter of George Rummage III and Lydia Martin Rummage. George III was the brother of David Rummage, Martha Jane's father, making Nancy and Martha first cousins.
Nancy and William had raised a large family of children and Nancy had passed away sometime between 1880 and 1889, when Millard was born.
Therein lies another mystery. Nancy Emaline Rummage married Isham Coley in Stanly County on May 29, 1859. They had one daughter, Ida May Coley, born November 3, 1861. Ida is living with Nancy and William H. H. Talbert in the 1880 census, along with her half-siblings. However, it did not appear that Isham Coley was yet deceased. It was probably a case of multiple Isham Coleys, cousins maybe, born relatively close in age.
Both Isham Coley's also served in the Civil War. One Isham Coley, the son of Susannah, died in 1862 and is buried in Virginia.
Name:
IshamColey
Birth Date:
1834
Age at Death:
28
Death Date:
28 Jun 1862
Burial Place:
Richmond, Richmond City, Virginia, USA
The other lived a long life and died in Stanly County in 1916. His father is listed as "Billie" on his death certificate, making this the Isham who was the son of William and Ann.
Name:
IshiamColey
Race:
White
Age:
77
Date of Birth:
1839
Date of Death:
7 Jun 1916
Death County:
Stanly
Death State:
North Carolina
Source Vendor:
NC State Archives. North Carolina Deaths, 1908-67
Nancy Emmaline Rummage, widow of Isham Coley, must have married William H. H. Talbert sometime soon after the death of her spouse in June of 1862.
The tombstone of the oldest son of William H. H. Talbert, John Harrison Talbert, shows his birthdate as April 6, 1861. The only way this would be possible is if Nancy Emmaline Rummage was not the first wife of William Talbert and John H. had a different mother.
His marriage license to Isabella Swearingen on February 11, 1897 in Cabarrus County, North Carolina, however lists his mother as Emmaline. The 1880 census show Ida Coley being 18 years of age and John H. Tolbert as being 14 years of age, so I have a tendancy to believe this spacing was more accurate and a birth year of 1861 is incorrect for him.
The youngest son of William H. H. and Nancy Emmaline Rummage Talbert was Richard M. Talbert, born in 1877. He never married and he and younger brother Millard, son on Martha Jane Rummage Talbert seemed to have hung pretty close at the seams as brothers.
Richard 'Tolbert' was the youngest son of William H. and Nancy Emmaline Rummage Talbert.
Lee was not actually a Talbert, but a Rummage, and the son of John Brantley Simpson and Martha Jane Rummage. Then 12 year old Millard was the son of William H. and Martha Jane together.
1910 show only Richard and Millard still living at home.
William H. H. Talbert died on June 26, 1917 at about 75 years of age, and is buried at Anderson Grove Baptist Church right outside of Albemarle, North Carolina.
Martha Jane lived for a few more decades. The 1910 census finds her living with her daughter, Mary Rummage Coley and family. Her relationship to head of household is shown as "Grandmother", however, she was actually his mother-in-law and grandmother of the children, which is what they probably meant when answering that question.
Martha Jane Rummage died on July 3, 1936. The informant was her son Lee Rummage, and her age given as "about 91". Cause of death says "No diagnosis". Martha was laid beside her dear husband, William H. H. Talbert at Anderson Grove Church.
The Children of Martha Jane Rummage Talbert:
1) Mary Elizabeth Rummage born September 20, 1871.
She married George C. Coley in Albemarle on April 30, 1900. He was 28 and she was 24. He listed his parent, J. A. and Eva Coley. She listed no parents at all. Mary died December 23, 1932 in Albemarle, Stanly County, North Carolina of Uterine Cancer. Her informant was her husband, George C. Coley. He gave her parents as John Rummage and her mother as Mrs. Martha Rummage, who was still living at the time of her death. He obviously knew Martha, and may have heard Mary give her father's name as "John", but it's doubtful he was a Rummage. The circumstances of Mary's birth was commonly swept under the carpet. Perhaps she was a child of John B. Simpson, as was her brother.
George and Mary had 7 children:
--George Washington Coley, born January 31, 1893. He served in WWI, married Iva Shehan and raised his family in Gastonia, North Carolina. He died on April 15, 1965 and is buried at Hollywood Cemetery in Gaston County.
--Clarence Calvin Coley, born September 5, 1896. He served in WWII and settled first in Norfolk, Virginia after leaving Stanly County. He married Beulah P. Carrico of West Virginia, and they settled after Norfolk, in South Charleston, West Virginia, where he died and was buried on February 16, 1949.
--Burl William Coley, born May 15, 1903. He served in WWII and married Molly Parker of Stanly County. They raised their family in New London, Stanly County, North Carolina. He died July 12, 1970.
-- Letha May Coley was the only daughter. She had 3 older brothers and 3 younger brothers.
She was born May 28, 1905. Letha May never married and spent her life in Stanly County. She died May 26, 1975.
--Frellan Alexander Coley, born July 21, 1907. He served in WWII and married Gladys Moline Dale.
They raised their family in Gastonia, North Carolina. He died on February 3, 1968.
--Glendon Lee Coley, born September 18, 1909. He served in WWII and married Rachel Beatrice Burleson of Stanly County. They lived for a while in Gaston County, but returned later to Stanly. He died February 5, 1978.
--Richard Guy Coley, born February 2, 1912. He served in WWII and married in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania to Rita Marie Detrano and settled in Virginia for the most part. He died May 20, 1954 and was buried in Alexandria, Virginia.
2) Richard Anderson Rummage was born January 5, 1874. The Rummage family had a neighbor named Richard Anderson with whom Martha's father David had business and land transactions with. Perhaps Richard A. Rummage was named for him. He married Rosa E. Leonard on October 13, 1901 in Albemarle. She was the daughter of J. W. and Laura Leonard. Richard gave for his parents only the name of his mother, Martha Rummage. Richard served in WWI and WWII. Richard died March 3, 1945 of a farm accident. The informant was "J. A. Rummage", and his mother was given as Martha Rummage and father unknown.
Richard and Rosa had 12 children:
1902 - 1979 Henry Clyde Rummage, married Myrtle Mae Morton
1905 - 1962 Lillie Mae Rummage, married James C Russell.
1906 - 1988 Eula Estelle Rummage, married Thomas Franklin Scott (1st), married Lonnie H. Blake (2nd)
1907 - 2002 Elcie Lee Rummage, married Ellan Gardner
1909 - 1968 John Earl Rummage, married Lucille Shaver
1913 - 2004 Nora Bell Rummage, married Woodrum Shaver
1915 - 2008 James Franklin Rummage, married Vivian Morton
1917 - 2006 Jay Dee Rummage, married Dorothy Poplin
1919 - 2004 Harold Richard Rummage, married Hazel Shaver
1921 - **** Winnie Louvenia Rummage, never married
1923 - 1983 Floyd Ray Rummage, married Isabella Norville Needham
1925 - 2007 Lettie Lucille Rummage, married Oliver Kipling Story
3) William Riley Rummage was born October 3, 1879, in Albemarle, NC. He died on October 5, 1982 in Gold Hill, Rowan County, NC. He was married to Margaret "Maggie" Hampton on November 1, 1906, in Albemarle, NC. She was the daughter of Levi Jackson Hampton and Lydia Beaver Hampton. They started their family in Albemarle, but later moved to Gold Hill, where they remained.
On Riley's marriage certificate he only gives his mother's name as "Rummage". No father listed.
On his death certificate, his wife was the informant. She gave his mother's name as Martha Rummage and his father as "Henry Rummage." Again, in cases like these, it is commonly not talked about to spouses or children in later years, except perhaps a brief mention, if any at all. This may have been a reference to William H. H. Talbert, his stepfather. Martha was never married to a Henry Rummage. Or, his father may have been a man named Henry, who gained Martha's surname on the death certificate, as in the case with John B Simpson becoming "John Rummage".
Oddly enough, there was another William Riley Rummage in the area. He was born in 1859 in Mecklenburg County, twenty years older than Martha Jane's William Riley. Ironically, he was the son of Henry A. Rummage and Jemima Rhodes Rummage and married Flora "Florence" Hopkins and died in Albemarle in 1939.
William Riley Rummage and Maggie Hampton Rummage had 5 children:
1907 - 1994 Mytle Irene Rummage, married EdgarMonroe Ketchie (1st), married Roy Thomas Morgan
1909 - 1965 Wade Allen Rummage, married Ethel Mae Shipton
1916 - 2008 Roy Jackson Rummage, married Ada Louise Buckley
1918 - 1968 George Henry Rummage, married Sadie Wagoner
1921 - 1981 Jesse Lee Rummage, married Dorothy B Shoe
4) Lee Allen Rummage was born March 23, 1882 in Albemarle, Stanly County, North Carolina and died on November 11, 1947 in Albemarle, North Carolina. He was married twice. First to Lou Tom Caudle, the mother of his three children, and daughter of Tom Caudle and Annie Ross Caudle. When she passed away on February 1, 1925, Lee married Lina Neal Lowder Mauldin, the daughter of Moses A. Lowder and Polly Ann Surratt Lowder and the widow of Jacob J (J. J) Mauldin.
Lee Allen, according to a Bond located in the court records of Stanly County, was the son of John Brantley Simpson, a married man, neighbor, and friend of Martha's father David Rummage. He had signed as witness to several land transactions involving the Rummage family and David specifically. Lee Allen did not acknowledge his biological father. On his marriage licenses, he only named his mother as Martha Talbert on one and Martha Rummage on the other, as she was married to William H. H. Talbert by that time.
He married first on November 22, 1905 and second on March 27, 1926.
When Lee Allen Rummage died of Cancer in 1947, the informant on his death certificate was his wife Livaneal or Lina Neal. She named his mother by her maiden name and in place of father was "Don't Know'. He was buried at Silver Springs Church south of Albemarle.
Lee and his first wife Lou Tom had three children:
1907 - 1957 Cletus Rummage, married Ruby Hinson
1913 - 1982 Marvin Reed Rummage, married Roxie Lowder
1917 - 1990 Winford Allen Rummage, married Evie Clegg Pickler
5) Millard Talbert
Millard Talbert was born Oct 10, 1889. He passed away March 4, 1943 at the age of 54. He was the only son Martha Jane Rummage had by husband William H. H. Talbert, as she was in her 40's when they wed.
There are no records that Millard ever married or had children. He stuck very close to his brother Richard Talbert. He had two half-brother named Richard, Richard Rummage and Richard Talbert.
Millard was a soldier, serving in WWI and sustaining an injury. His obituary in the Greensboro Daily News stated that he had served in many battles. His registration describes him as Medium build with blue eyes and brown hair.
Like many soldiers, Millard became a victim of war and never recovered. He returned a troubled soul.
His death certificate stated that he passed away of Chronic Alchoholism.
Martha Jane Rummage was a woman of more than a little mystery. She must have been a beauty as she seemed to have beguiled a number of men in the community around her. She had at least one child with John Brantley Simpson. Her last son was by William H. H. Talbert, who married her when their son, Millard, was 3. Was son Richard Anderson Rummage named after neighbor Richard Anderson? Was it because Mr. Anderson was a dear friend of the family, helped her out in an era where women had a difficult time supporting themselves? Or was there another reason? Who was John listed on daughter Mary's death certificate? And who was Henry listed on son William Riley Rummages? But of all the mystery surrounding Martha Jane, the biggest mystery was the following document:
From familysearch.org, the marriage license of Martha J Rummage, daughter of David and Beady, and William C. Foard, son of John C Foard and Mary Ann Osborne.
Who was William C. Foard? If they were married, why does Martha appear in the 1880 census as a Rummage? Why do her older children all bear the name Rummage throughout their lives and not the name of Foard? They married on March 2, 1871. Oldest daughter Mary was born September 20, 1871, just 6 months later? Why was she not a Foard?
This might take some looking into. Perhaps the land records will help tell a tale. Several passed in connection with her father and sister Bettie and Bettie's husband Balaam A. Carter, who was no less mysterious. But those are other posts....
Many times, descendants will start a family with only the children who show up in the 1850 census, while the 1840 and 1830 census show other, older "dashes" who could be children, possibly those who are grown up and on their own by 1850. If the parents die intestate and no land records indicate descendants, then there is nothing to tie these older, independent children to their parents.
Millard Talbert was born Oct 10, 1889. He passed away March 4, 1943 at the age of 54. He was the only son Martha Jane Rummage had by husband William H. H. Talbert, as she was in her 40's when they wed.
